<<

. 2
( 2)



8. CM. HanpMMep: ˜ P ˜ ˜ M H C K M ˜BMT- action) OCTaeTCR 3a 3aCTpaXOBaHHblM, npM M.M., BMTPRHCKMR n o r o e o p ˜ o e
B.B. npa-
M.M., ˜
npaeo. K H M ˜ UeCCMM Xe npaB0 ˜ p e 6 0 ˜ a T b BO3MeueHMR 60. K H M nepean: 0 6 u ˜ nonoxeHm.
˜˜ e
P R H C K M ˜B.B. A o r o e o p ˜ o e ˜
nepsan: O 6 u ˜ nonoxeHMR. M.: ( ( C T ˜ T Y T ˜ y6blTK0˜ nepeX0aMTK CTpaXOBuMKy. B 3 ˜ 0 i C. 468).
e ,
CBR3M B03HMKaeT BOnpOC: clT0 nepeXOaMT K 23. O o r e n b c o ˜10.6. C y G p o r a u ˜ ˜npM
2001. C. 476; r p a w a ˜ c ˜ npaeo. Ycle6-
oe
c-rpaxoeuwy npM c y 6 p o r a u ˜ ecnu cTpa-
˜, cTpaxoeaHMM r p y 3 0 ˜ .C ˜ p a x o e o e aeno.
HHK. qacrb 1. f l o pea. A.n. Cepreeea, 10.K.
˜
XoeaTenb ece e u e OcTaeTcR Y'iacTHMKoM Mlonb. C. 19.
Tonc˜oro. M., 1998. C. 526.
9. n p v l 3 ˜ a e a n .c l ˜ o OnpeAeneHHb˜x crpaxoeoro 0 6 ˜ 3 a ˜ e n b c ˜npyraq nocTa-
sa? 24. ˜ P ˜ ˜ M H CM.M., ˜ BMTPRHCKMR B.B.
KH ˜
B
HoeKa eonpoca: Konb c ˜ o p o cTpaxoeaTenb
cnyranx CTOPOH˜IMoryT npecneaoeaTb M noroeop˜oe npaeo. K ˜ f l r a
nepeaq: 0 6 u ˜ e
OCTaeTCR BOBnecleHHblM B 06R3aTenb˜TB0, nonoxeHM8. C. 476.
MHble HeMaTepManbHble UenM (AapeHMe,
KaKoe npaeo y Hero ocTaeTcR, ecnM crpa- 25. Hoeocenosa J . A . l l e p e ˜ e ˜ a B nvlu
nomepTeoeaHne, c n o ˜ c o p c ˜ ˜ o M ntibre
X O B u M K nOCne BblnnaTbl B03MeueHMR npM- 06˜3aTenb˜T˜e. ˜ ˜ x A ˜ M M H H npaeo)),
6e3603Me3gHble TMnbl A O ˜ O B O ˜ O B ) , UleAyeT ((˜
06pe˜ae˜ npaeo Tpe60˜aTbB b l n n a c l e H ˜ ˜ i N!! 12, aeKa6pb 2001 r.
nOaclepKHyTb, 'iTO TaKMe CflyclaM RBnRloTCR
C Y M M ˜ I TpeTbero nnua?
c 26. H ˜ HenOHRTHa HeyBepeHHOCTb 3aKO-
M
cKopee McKnloqeHMeM˜3 o6uero npaemna,
M.M., BMTPRHCKM˜ 8.8. Hoaa-renfi B Tex cnyclafix, Koraa KOHCTPYK-
17. ˜ P B ˜ M H C K M ˜
cleM caMMM npaeMnoM.
˜ O ˜ O B O ˜ H O ˜ K H MTpeTbR: Aoro-
npaB0. ˜˜ L(MR c y 6 p o r a u ˜ ˜
IlpMMeHReTCR B 3aKO-
10 H e o 6 x o a ˜ ˜ o yKa3aTb AaXe Ha 'iMCT0
BOpbl 0 BblnOnHeHMM pa6o-r Ll OKa3aHMM
TepMMHonorHclecKoe HecxoncTBo cy6pora- HOAaTenbHblX aKTaX 6e3 MCnOnb30BaHMR
U M M YCTynKM IlpaBa T ˜ ˜ ˜ O B ˜ HCM R . O ycnyr. C. 582. COOTBeTCTByloUerO Ha3BaHMR. B claCTHOCTM,
W ˜M
18. 6 p a r M H ˜ ˜ M h M.M., B M T P R H C KB.B.
M˜ peclb MaeT IlpaKTMcleCKM060 BCeX 3aKOHaX
cnoeo ((ycTynKa)) npeanonaraeT Hanpae-
Aoroeop˜oe npaeo. K H Mnepean: 0 6 u ˜ e 06 06R3aTenbHbl˜
˜˜
neHHoe Boneeoe a e i c ˜ e v l e nMqa, npaea BMaaX crpaxoeaHMR, rae
nonoxeHMrr. C. 477.
KoToporo nepeaalo-rcn ApyroMy nMuy. BMeCTO nOHRTMR " c y 6 p o r a u ˜ ˜ MCnOnb-
))
19, ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ H H C K B H T P R H C KB.B.
M.M,, M ˜ M˜
npaaa ( ( y c ˜ y n a l o ˜ c ˜ ) ) . 3yeTCR 0 6 0 ˜ ((npaBO o 6 p a ˜ ˜ o ˜ o e 6 o -
0˜ rp
M.M , BHTPFIHCKM˜ A o r o e o p ˜ o e npaeo. K H MTpeTbfl: n o r o -
˜˜ BBHMR)), clTO, KPOMe BCerO npO'ier0, TaMT
11 CM.: 6parMH˜KMfi 8.8.
floroeop˜oenpaeo. K H MnepeaR: 0 6 u ˜ e BOPbl 0 BblnOJlHeHMM pa6o-r M OKa3aHMM
˜˜ B ce6e yrpO3y B03HMKHOBeHMR He˜epHblx
ycnyr. C. 578-590. C Y ˜ ˜ 0 npMMeHeHMM B TaKOM Cnyclae
nonomeHMR. C. 476. HM˜
20. TaM me. C. 579. KOHCTPYK˜MMperpecca,
12. M3 BCeX BMAOB MMYU(eCTBeHHOr0CTpa-
21. T ˜ KCTaTbR 3 8 4 rpa)l(FlaH˜K˜r˜
, K0,QeKCa 27. T a ˜ o e ˜ O ˜ O C H O B ˜ H(0 O ˜ H cMny OT-
XOBaHMR JlMlLlb B OAHOM CnYclae HeB03- H
K a 3 a x c ˜ oCCP ( O C O ˜ ˜ H H ˜ R OT 28
i clac˜b)
MOXHO HacTynnenMe cTpaxoeoro cnyclarr CYTCTBMR KaK HOPMaTMBHbIX, TBK M YKa-
˜ e ˜ a 6 p n roaa ycTaHaenMeana, rTo
1963
BCneACTBMe A ˜ ˜ ˜ C T B M ˜ nMu. Peclb
TpeTbMX 3aHHblX AaHHbIM aBTOpOM O ˜ C T O R T ˜ ˜ ˜ C T B )
K CTP˜XOBOR OpraHM3auMM, y i l f l a ˜ k l ˜ ˜ e fn p ˜ 3 ˜ paccMaTpMsaeMoro cnyclan
i
VAeT o cTpaxoeaHmM npeanpMtiMMaTenb- a˜˜e
cTpaxoeoe e o 3 ˜ e u e no˜BMyuecTeeti-
˜e cy6porau˜eA MOXeT AaTb OCHOBaHMR anR
CKOrO PMCKa. n a ˜ ˜ b B fMia CTpaXOBaHMR
l
H O M crpaxoeaHMlo, nepexonMT B npeaenax own60r˜oro paccuoTpeHMn B KarecTse
npeaycuaTpneaeT nea B O ˜ M O X H ˜ I X cTpa- ˜
TO!? CYMMbl npaBO T ˜ ˜ ˜ O B ˜ HKOTOpOe c y 6 p o r a u nlo6oro cnyclan nepexoaa npae
˜˜
xoeblx cnyclaR: HacTynnetine Y ˜ ˜ I T K OOT MR,
B
AetlTenbHocTM 143- c-rpaxoea-renb ( M ˜ w o e nMuo, nonyclm-
M
npeanp˜˜n˜a˜enbc˜oR KpeaMTopa Ha ocHoeaHw 3 a ˜ o ˜ o a a ˜ e n b -
wee cTpaxoeoe e o 3 ˜ e u e ˜ MMeeT K ˜e)
3a HapyLueHMR CBOMX 0 6 ˜ 3 a T e n b ˜ ˜ ˜ KOHTpa- HOrO aKTa.
reHTaMh c ˜ p a x o e a ˜ e n ˜ - n p e p . n p ˜ ˜ nML(y,˜OTBeTCTBeHHOMy 3a n p k l ' i k l ˜ e ˜ ˜ b l i 28. n o AaHHOMY BOnPOCY Henb3R COrIIa-
˜˜a en˜
(1) MnM ecneAcTeMe H ˜ M ˜ H ˜ HyM R o e ˜ h y u e p 6 . Q)˜pManbHblM nPM3HaKOM TOTO,
cn CMTbCR C A.r. ˜˜M˜I,˜HK yKa3blBaK)uMM.
TO nepexop, npae cTpaxoeaTenR, npeayc-
yKa3aHHoi AeRTenbHOCTM no He3aBMCRuMM cl˜o paccMa-rpMeaeMbleAeeRTb c ˜ a ˜ e k (CT.
OT npeanpMHMMaTenR 0 6 c r o ˜ ˜ ˜ C T B ˜ M , M O T P ˜ H H ˜ C ˜ ˜ T B Y ˜ ˜ U K M r H (CT. 840). CT, 339-347 r K ) OTBeneHbl nMWb YCTYnKe
en ˜I !
AOnXeH PaCCMaTpMBaTbCR q KacleCTBe npaBa Tpe606a˜MR(cM.: A M A ˜ H K o A.r.
BKJiDclaR PMCK HenOny'ieHMR OXMnaeMblX
c y 6 p o r a u ˜ ˜ ,He perpecca, cnyxn-r, B
a Yc˜yn˜a npaea ˜ p e 6 0 e a ˜ M R . T p a x ˜ a ˜ c ˜ o e
f l O X O ˜ O B (2). H ˜ B O ˜ M O X H O C T ˜
HaCTynne-
clacTtiocTM, nonomewe o TOM, c l ˜ o npaeo 3aKOH0,QaTenbCTBO:C T ˜ T ˜ M M M ˜ H T ˜ P H M .
KO.
HMR nocnep,Hero eM, , cTpaxosoro cnyrafl
oa
nepeuenwee K cTpaxosuM- npaKTMKa. BblnycK 19. AnMaTbl: DPMCT.
M3-3a A ˜ ˜ C T B M ˜ TPeTbMX nMU, OcleBMAHa, T˜˜˜OB˜HMR,
scneBcTBMe qero npMHuMn c y 6 p o r a u ˜ ˜ KY, OCYueCTBnReTCR MM C C O ˜ ˜ D ˜ ˜ H 2004. M 30). M ˜ C.
e
npaenn, perynMpyrouMx OTHoweHMfl Mex- 29. r p a x n a ˜ c KoaeKc PK ( 0 6 ˜ a f i
˜˜i
3TOM UlY'iae ˜ ˜ ˜ ! ? c T B o 6y/J,eT.˜
He B ˜ T
ay c-rpaxoea-renehn ( 3 a c ˜ p a x o e a ˜ ˜M 1 ˜' i)a c ˜ b ) . K O M M ˜ H T ˜ o cM ˜ T ˜ ˜ H ˜ I ! ? ) .
b
13. Ueafirep˜ KZ?T˜ B B ˜ A ˜BH M ˜
K., cpae- ( ˜T
X.
nMuOM, OTBeTCTBeHHblM 38 Y ˜ ˜ I T K (n. 2
HMTenbHoe npaeoeeaeHMe B c@epe clac-r- K H M 2. OTB. pea.: M.K. C y n e i ˜ e ˜ o e ,
˜˜
M
HOrO npaea. TOM 2. M.: MeXa˜Hap˜flHble CT. 840). C ˜ a 3 a ˜ ˜ o 3 e o n ˜ e ˜ noe cAenaTb 10.r. ˜ ˜ C M AnMaTbl: XeTi Xaprbl. 2003.
H.
BblBOP, 0 TOM, '-IT0 B OTCYTCTBMe B CTaTbe C. 332.
OTHOLUeHMR. 2000. C. 160-179.
3 8 4 r K Ka3CCP npasMna, aHanorwHoro
14. CM.: Prlnc˜ples f European contract law
o 30. BOBCeX npeAblAy˜MX pa6o˜ax QeHTpOM
n. 2 CT. 840 neRc˜sylou,erorK, peclb Luna
http://www.lexrnercatorra.
(B M H T ˜ ˜ H ˜ T ˜ : BHMMaHMR RBnflnaCb HeflOCpeJl,CTBeHHO
0 BO3HMKHOBeHMM HOBOrO (perpeccHor0) caMa c y 6 p o r a u ˜CM. Hanpmep: 6parMH-
˜.
org).
06˜3aTenb˜T˜a. CKMR M.M., BMTPRHCKMR A O ˜ O B O ˜ H O ˜
B.B
15. CM.: Zhen Jlng. The confus˜on between
22. K clMCnY O T ˜ M ˜ ˜ M ˜ cy6pora-
MeXaY npaeo. KHMra nepeafl: 0 6 w e nonomeHcIfl.
subrogation and assignment In the Insurance
1 ˜ M e fM PerpeCCOM MOXHO nPMclMyMTb M
i C.466-477; r p a w a ˜ c ˜ npaeo. Y C I ˜ ˜ H M K .
oe
Law o f the Peoples' Republ˜c f China 1995
o
q a c ˜ b no^ pea. A.fl. Cepreeea, 0 . K .
cneaylouee oTnMcll/te M e w y perpeccoM M 1
- A critical analysts on Artlcle 4 4 o f the
'
ueCcMeG, npM˜eaeHH0e M.M. ˜ P ˜ ˜ M H ˜ K T o n c ˜ o r o .M., 1998. C. 525-527; 6enblx
MM:
Insurance Law. Journal o f Bus˜ness Law.
((flpm˜u˜n˜anb˜oe ˜cl˜e pa3n perpecca M B.C., Kpmoweee M.B. C˜paxoeoe npaeo.
2002. Nov, p. 608-625.
uCCCMM COCTOMT yXe B CaMOM 3Ha'ieHMM M.: M3aa˜enbcreo HOPMA. 2002. C. 93-95;
16. B TOM Xe MCTO'iHMKe YTBepwaeTCR, ' i T 0
cyqecTeeHHoe p a 3 n ˜ c l ˜ ee w y uecc˜eG MX Anrr cooTeeTcTBylouero npaea: perpecc r p a w a ˜ c ˜ npaeo. TOM1. A ˜ a n e ˜ ˜ c l e c -
oe
M
nopowaeT npaeo, a npM ueccMM nepeaa- KMRKYPC. OTB. pea.: M.K. C y n e i ˜ e ˜ o e ,
bl c y 6 p o r a u ˜ e ACOCTOMT B TOM, 'iTO npM
e C 803HMKLuee npaB0)) (CM.: ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ M H C 0.r. 6 a c ˜ nAJlMaTbl, 2000. C. 579.
TR KMR .
cy6poraq˜˜ npaeo T ˜ ˜ ˜ O B ˜(chose in
HMR

<<

. 2
( 2)